Support Higher Plain Games on Patreon

A Sketchbook About Her Sun – Review

I like trying out games that are attempting something a little different even if that means it’s more of a concept in progress rather than a fully formed execution. A Sketchbook About Her Sun is not a game in the strictest sense – its an album by a band called Red Ribbon that has been visualised into a visual novel. As the music plays, you’ll watch some semi-static images illustrate the album’s story and make some choices on screen.

As a concept, the idea of an interactive album is a great one. Red Ribbon’s album called ‘Planet X’ is an indie rock album and has a few catchy tunes mixed in with some moody slow to medium tempo tracks. It’s a little muddy but plays the indie rock vibe relatively straight and safe. The music is fine and the images themselves are nice too. The problem here comes with the lack of real interaction or influence from the player on what is going on. You are given a few cues to affect some of the onscreen graphics or minimal design choices. Ultimately, nothing really changes and the outcome is the same but that’s going to be the case because the music will always be the same for fully composed songs. It’s an experience that’s over in 35 minutes and unless you really like specific songs there is no incentive to return.

Whilst your choices change some of the visuals on screen, the story doesn’t change.

However, the concept itself has really fascinated me. I wonder if by leaning in to the choices matter idea you can have an album that weaves through 6 of 10-12 tracks dynamically through choices you make to build your own EP. I’ve also seen elsewhere an album that translates tracks into tarot cards and let you shuffle the album and play the cards as a deck. I feel like this concept is a great one and could be mined for loads of ideas and slants on albums as games to be explored. Look at what Sayonara Wild Hearts did for example. This game is a much more modest toe dip into the merger of games and album music and a a result it feels more of a curious oddity rather than a fully formed product.

A Sketchbook About Her Sun
Final Thoughts
A great concept to merge album with choice based gaming visuals but ultimately it is a very light product that doesn't quite land its execution.
Positives
A unique idea for a game that plays the music along with a visual novel styled comic.
Some good tunes!
Negatives
Ultimately, the interactions available are very surface level deep.
6
Fine

Higher Plain Games is part of the Higher Plain Network. If you like what I do, please consider supporting me via Patreon for as little as $1/£1 a month. There are additional perks for supporting me there such as behind the scenes content and downloads. You can also share the website or use the affiliate buy now links on reviews. Buying credit from CD Keys using that link means I get a couple of pence per sale. All your support will enable me to produce better content, more often. Thank you.

%d bloggers like this: